In this article, we would like to talk about a Gift of a Spanish Property. In the past few months we have received a significant number of enquiries from individuals, normally Non Tax Residents in Spain and normally of British nationality, telling us that they were advised to GIFT their property to an English limited company (set up by them only for this purpose) in order to avoid INHERITANCE TAX (IHT) in Spain at the time of Death for the transfer of their property. Also, they were informed that IHT in Spain is charged at 40% of the value of the estate for Non Residents. For this reason, we want to cover this subject again this week, as we understand that there could be serious consequences caused by following this advice.
Inheritance tax
First of all we would like to clarify that we understand that even if you transfer a Gift of a Spanish Property to a company, by sale, or any other way, and the company has no real activity and its only asset is the property, when the shareholder passes away their shares must be transferred to their heirs and the shares will represent the ownership of the Spanish property so, theoretically the inheritance tax (IHT) should be paid anyway.
Foremost, one must take into account the fact that Spanish IHT, as applied to Non Tax Residents, is calculated on a sliding scale. The minimum percentage is 7.65% and the maximum is 34%, therefore the average % is 20.82% and not the 40% mentioned above.
These clients also told us that they were advised to transfer the property to a limited company incorporated in the United Kingdom by means of a GIFT, as the companies are not subject and do not pay Gift Tax, so for the Gift Deed, the only taxes to be paid are 1% Stamp Duty (AJD), that means 1% of the declared value of the property.
We agree with the fact that companies do not pay gift tax, but we understand that when a company receives a gift, the company will need to pay company tax ( Impuesto de Sociedades) if is a Spanish SL or Income Tax for Non Residents (19%) if the company is an English Limited company, as in this case.
This means in practice, as per our interpretation of the Income Tax for Non Resident Law (Real Decreto Legislativo 5/2004), that if you are a Non Resident and you make a gift of a Spanish Property to an English limited company, you should pay 1% Stamp Duty as mentioned before, but also the company must pay as per the article 25.1.F of the RDL 5/2004 a 19% tax for the gain obtained (value of the property). If the company does not declare this tax in the Income Tax Declaration as Non Resident, it could suffer an inspection and be subject to penalty proceedings.
Conclusion.
If a Non Resident Tax couple decide to GIFT a property of a value of 200.000€ to an English limited company, the taxes to be paid should be 1% Stamp Duty (which amount 2.000€) and also the company should declare the gift in its Non Resident Tax Declaration, paying 19%, which amounts 38.000€. The total tax payable in this scenario would be 40.000€, this being significantly higher than the Inheritance Tax (Impuesto Sucesiones) that they are trying to avoid.
Spanish taxman criteria
As we mentioned in a previous article, the General Tax Office
(Dirección General de Tributos) made this point very clearly in the Consultation number 2017-04. This involved a French Institution that was a beneficiary of a Spanish Inheritance, and it was held that in this scenario the inheritance or gift are not subject to Inheritance or Gift Tax, but there must be paid Income Tax for Non Residents when the recipient is a company non resident in Spain.
Therefore, if you want to transfer your property owned personally to a non Spanish Company, there are better options available than to do so as a gift. And if the purpose is to minimise or avoid Spanish inheritance tax, we understand that are often better and more effective ways to do it. Please if you are worried about the IHT to be paid in Spain then come and see us we will be more than pleased to assist you.
*The information provided on this article is not intended to be legal advice, but merely conveys general information related to legal issues.
White & Baos
Carlos Baos ( Abogado / Lawyer)
Tel: 966 426 185
E-mail: info@white-baos.com
**(Located at the Glorieta (Square end) of Marques de Campo)
© White & Baos 2010 – All rights reserved
